Describe the formation and functions of the Inter-State Council. State some of the important decisions taken by the Inter-State Council in the last 3 years.

by

The Inter-State Council: Formation, Functions, and Recent Decisions

Introduction:

The Inter-State Council (ISC) is a crucial constitutional body in India established under Article 263 of the Constitution. Its primary purpose is to foster cooperation and coordination between the Union and the States, thereby promoting federalism. While its establishment is constitutionally mandated, its actual formation and activation have been somewhat delayed. The council’s significance lies in its potential to resolve inter-state disputes, harmonize policies, and ensure a smooth functioning of the federal structure. The lack of consistent activity in the past has, however, raised concerns about its effectiveness. This response will describe the council’s formation, its functions, and highlight some of its significant decisions in the last three years (2020-2023). The approach will be primarily factual, drawing upon official government documents and news reports.

Body:

1. Formation of the Inter-State Council:

Article 263 empowers the President to constitute the ISC. However, it’s not mandatory. The council’s formation remained dormant for a long time until its reconstitution in 1990. The Prime Minister chairs the council, with the Chief Ministers of all states and Union Territories with legislatures as members. The Union Ministers are also included as members, depending on the agenda. The council’s secretariat is usually provided by the Ministry of Home Affairs. The composition ensures representation from both the Union and the States, reflecting the federal nature of the Indian polity.

2. Functions of the Inter-State Council:

The ISC’s functions are broad and encompass various aspects of inter-state relations:

  • Resolving Inter-State Disputes: The council serves as a platform to address disputes between states concerning water sharing, boundary demarcation, and other resource allocation issues.
  • Promoting Coordination: It facilitates coordination on matters of common interest, such as disaster management, environmental protection, and economic development.
  • Harmonizing Policies: The ISC aims to harmonize policies across states, ensuring uniformity and preventing inconsistencies that could hinder national progress.
  • Providing Recommendations: The council can provide recommendations to the Union and State governments on various policy matters. These recommendations, while not legally binding, carry significant weight due to the council’s composition and the involvement of key political leaders.

3. Important Decisions in the Last Three Years (2020-2023):

Precisely pinpointing all decisions made by the ISC in the last three years requires access to confidential meeting minutes, which are not publicly available. However, based on publicly available information, it’s difficult to identify specific, major decisions taken exclusively by the ISC during this period. The ISC’s activity level has been subject to criticism for being inconsistent. News reports often highlight discussions and consultations on various issues, but concrete decisions announced as direct outcomes of ISC meetings are less frequent. This lack of transparency hinders a comprehensive assessment of its recent work.

4. Challenges and Limitations:

The ISC faces several challenges:

  • Lack of Regular Meetings: The infrequent meetings limit its effectiveness in addressing emerging issues promptly.
  • Non-Binding Recommendations: The non-binding nature of its recommendations can weaken its influence on policy decisions.
  • Political Considerations: Political considerations can sometimes overshadow the council’s objective approach to resolving inter-state disputes.

Conclusion:

The Inter-State Council, though constitutionally mandated, has faced challenges in fulfilling its potential. While its formation ensures representation from both the Union and States, its effectiveness is hampered by infrequent meetings and the non-binding nature of its recommendations. The lack of publicly available information regarding its recent decisions makes a detailed analysis difficult. To enhance the ISC’s role, a more structured approach with regular meetings, transparent decision-making processes, and mechanisms to ensure the implementation of its recommendations is crucial. Strengthening the ISC is vital for fostering cooperative federalism and promoting holistic development across India, upholding the constitutional values of unity and integrity. Greater transparency and proactive engagement by the council are essential to realize its full potential in resolving inter-state disputes and harmonizing policies for the benefit of all citizens.

APPSC GROUP 1 Notes brings Prelims and Mains programs for APPSC GROUP 1 Prelims and APPSC GROUP 1 Mains Exam preparation. Various Programs initiated by APPSC GROUP 1 Notes are as follows:- For any doubt, Just leave us a Chat or Fill us a querry––